U.S. Thanksgiving resembles festivals around the world

This painting by Jean Louis Gerome Ferris, "The first Thanksgiving 1621," shows Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing food. (© Everett Collection/Shutterstock)
This painting by Jean Louis Gerome Ferris, “The first Thanksgiving 1621,” shows Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing food. (© Everett Collection/Shutterstock)

Like its cousins Sukkot, Chuseok, Day of the Dead, and others, Thanksgiving centers around giving thanks for the harvest, enjoying bountiful food, and spending time with family and friends. Harvest festivals started in an agrarian era when crop yields could mean the difference between life and death.

A woman participates in a Day of the Dead celebration on November 2 in Mexico City. (© Hector Vivas/Getty Images)

“You get to eat and celebrate not having to starve all winter, and it’s time to celebrate after the work of gathering the harvest,” says John Turner, professor of religious studies and history at George Mason University in Virginia.

Unlike the other celebrations, Thanksgiving focuses on an American origin story. In 1621, Pilgrims were new to the land, and Wampanoag tribe members who taught the Pilgrims to grow the crops they needed to survive shared what is considered the first Thanksgiving meal. In recent years, Americans have become more sensitized to the contributions of the Wampanoag and also the fact that the feast did not fully represent the relationship between the English settlers and the Wampanoag and other native tribes — it followed almost 100 years of contact with other Europeans and the decimation of many tribes by conflicts and disease.

Even at the first Thanksgiving meal, the settlers and the natives were distrustful of each other, Turner points out.

“By 1675 the relationship had degenerated into one of conflict and war,” according to the Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian (PDF, 4.3MB). “This would be the history of most relationships between Natives and non-Natives for the next two hundred years.”

Over the centuries, Americans, like people in other countries, celebrated periodically when fall crop yields were plentiful and also marked religious days of “thanksgiving” for the blessings in their lives — such as the end of the drought, recovery from disease, or victory in battle.

It wasn’t until 1863, during the Lincoln presidency and the Civil War, that Thanksgiving became a national holiday. The day “was intended to celebrate America, to be a rite of unification,” says Lucy Long, director of the Center for Food and Culture in Bowling Green, Ohio.

A woman observes the annual Chuseok holiday by placing a flower on an altar near the Demilitarized Zone separating North and South Korea. (© Anthony Wallace/Getty Images)

Here are some of Thanksgiving’s global cousins:

  • Chuseok, in Korea, is a massive harvest festival that features fall foods like persimmon, chestnuts, and rice cakes called songpyeon. “Those are seasonal foods in the way we in the U.S. have pumpkin, corn, and apples,” Long says. South Koreans travel to their ancestral homes to be with family for the three-day holiday. Like in the United States, it is one of the busiest travel times of the year.
  • Día de Los Muertos (Day of the Dead) in Mexico started as an Aztec tradition but now coincides with the Catholic All Souls’ Day. Families spend time together as they make food offerings to honor and connect with their ancestors.
  • Sukkot is celebrated by Jews around the world to mark the biblical-era Israelites’ decades in the wilderness, says Rachelle “Riki” Saltzman, lecturer in folklife at the University of Oregon. Like Thanksgiving, Sukkot celebrates the harvest and the past. “It enacts ‘This is who we are as a people,’” she adds.
A Jewish worshipper holds the four plant species — palm leaf fronds, citrus fruit, myrtle leaves and willow branches — used while praying to mark Sukkot. (© Emmanuel Dunand/AFP/Getty Images)

Today, Americans see the Thanksgiving holiday as a day to be with their extended families, Turner says. They watch parades and football games, shop at pre-holiday sales, donate to charities and partake in homemade feasts. In the melting pot of America, many immigrant families bring their own traditional foods (such as Lao rice or enchiladas) to serve alongside the traditional turkey and harvest vegetables. The heart of the holiday, Turner says, is family.